A Critical Evaluation of Natural Gas-water Formula Correlations

Main Article Content

V. J. Aimikhe
M. A. Adeyemi

Abstract

The performance evaluation of fourteen (14) formula correlations for predicting the water content of natural gas in equilibrium with water, and the suitability of some of these correlations in predicting the water content of natural gas in equilibrium with hydrates, has been presented. Also presented was an evaluation of acid gas and gravity correction factor correlations. The evaluation was achieved by using the cubic plus association equation of state - CPA EoS, published experimental water content data from a tuneable diode laser adsorption spectrometer, and data from the gas processors supplier’s association (GPSA) chart, to validate the results of the correlations. The results of the validation showed that for the prediction of the water content of natural gas in equilibrium with water, the Bukacek correlation was best suited for low pressures of 1 and 2.5 MPa at a temperature range of 9 to 58°C. The modified ideal model (MIM) correlation was the best for pressures of 5 and 10 MPa, at temperature range of 30 to 89.6°C The Aimikhe correlation was best suited for pressures of 7.5 MPa, at a temperature range of 30 to 86°C, while the Khaled’s correlation performed better for high pressures of 25 and 50 MPa, at a temperature range of 30 to 91.5°C. The Maddox correction factor had better accuracy than other acid gas correction factors when accounting for the presence of acid gases. The Mohammadi or Chapoy gravity correction factors were the best correlations for accounting for the presence of heavy components in natural gas. For processed methane-rich natural gas in equilibrium with hydrates at a temperature range of -20 to 10°C, the Lin correlation was best suited for pressures of 2.5 and 5 MPa while the MIM correlation performed better at pressures of 7.5, 15 and 20 MPa.

Keywords:
Natural gas water content, heavy hydrocarbon correction factor, salinity correction factor, acid gas.

Article Details

How to Cite
Aimikhe, V. J., & A. Adeyemi, M. (2020). A Critical Evaluation of Natural Gas-water Formula Correlations. Journal of Scientific Research and Reports, 25(6), 1-20. https://doi.org/10.9734/jsrr/2019/v25i630206
Section
Original Research Article

References

Burgass R, Chapoy A, Tohidi B. Low-temperature water content in natural gas systems: New measurements and modeling. Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Gas Hydrates. Beijing, China; 2014.

Mohammadi AH, Chapoy A, Tohidi B, Richon D. A semi-empirical approach for estimating the water content of natural gases. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 2004;43:7137-7147.

Lin Z, Junming F, Jia Z, Li Q, Luling L. Formula calculation methods of water content in sweet natural gas and their adaptability analysis. Natural Gas Industry B. 2015;1(2):144 –149.

Torbjørn VL, Anita B, Kjersti OC, Cecilie FN, Even S. Water content of high-pressure natural gas: Data, prediction and experience from field. Proceedings of the International Gas Union Research Conference. Paris, France. 2008;1– 43.

Ayobi M, Shahhosseini S, Behjat Y. CFD simulation and experimental study on CO2 capture in fluidized bed reactor using dry potassium-based sorbent. Petroleum and Coal. 2019;61(5):949-964.

McKeogh G. Moisture Measurement Technologies for Natural Gas. GE Measurement & Control; 2000.

Cook C. Devices for Field Determination of water in Natural gas. Spectra Sensors Inc. Texas; 2006.

Kontogeorgis GM, Voutsas EC, Yakoumis IV, Tassios DP. An equation of state for associating fluids. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. Research. 1999; 35(11):4310–4318.

Erbar JH, Jagota AK, Muthswamy S, Moshfeghian M. Predicting synthetic gas and natural gas thermodynamic properties using a modified Soave Redlich-Kwong equation of state. GPA Research Report. 1980;42.

Twu CH, Coon JE, Cunningham JR. A new generalized alpha function for cubic for Estimating the Water Content of Natural Gases. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 1995;43.

ISO 18453. Natural gas - Correlation between water content and water dew point; 2004.

Li Z, Firoozabadi A. Cubic-plus-association equation of state for water-containing mixtures: Is “cross association” necessary? AIChE J. 2009;55(7):1803–1813.

Zirrahi M, Azin R, Hassanzedeh H, Moshfeghian, M. Prediction of water content of sour and acid gases. Fluid Phase Equilibria. 2010;299:171–179.

Chapoy A, Haghighi H, Burgass R, Tohidi, B. Gas hydrates in low water content gases: Experimental measurements and modeling using the CPA equation of state. Fluid Phase Equilibria. 2010;296:9–14.

McKetta JJ, Wehe AH. Use this chart for water content of natural gases. Petroleum Refining. (Hydrocarbon. Processing.) 1958;37:153.

Katz DL Cornell, Kobayashi DR, Poettmann F. Handbook of Natural Gas Engineering, McGraw-Hill Book Company; 1959.

Gordon W. New charts provide accurate estimates water content of sour Natural Gas. Oil & Gas Journal. 2003;64-66.

Campbell JM. Gas conditioning and processing (8th ed.). Oklahoma: Campbell Petroleum Series; 2004.

Guo B, Ghalambor A. Natural Gas Engineering Handbook. Gulf Publishing Company, Houston, USA; 2005.

Sloan E, Khoury F, Kobayashi R. Measurement and interpretation of the water content of a methane-propane mixture in the gaseous state in equilibrium with hydrate. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Fundamentals. 1982;21(4):391-395.

Ning Y, Zhang H, Zhou G. Mathematical simulation and program for water content chart of natural gas. Chemical Engineering. Oil and Gas. 2000;29:75-77.

Khaled AAF. A prediction of water content in sour natural gas. Final Research Report, King Saud University. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; 2007.

Bahadori A, Vuthaluru HB, Mokhatab S. Rapid estimation of the water content of sour natural gases. Journal of Japan Petroleum Institute. 2009;52(5):270-274.

Ghiasi M, Bahadori, A. A new correlation for accurate estimation of natural gases water content. Petroleum and coal. 2014; 56(5):582-594.

Aimikhe VJ, Joel OF, Ikiensikimama SS. A new normograghic based correlation for predicting water content of sweet natural gases. Journal of Engineering Science and Technology (JESTEC). 2020;15(1):184-197.

Behr WR. Correlation eases absorber-equilibrium-line calculations for TEG-natural gas dehydration. Oil & Gas Journal. 1983;81(45):96-98.

Kazim FM. Quickly calculate the water content of natural gas. Hydrocarbon Processing. 1996;105-108.

Wang Junqi. The simple method of calculating water content in natural gas. Chemical Engineering. Oil and Gas. 1994; 23(3):192-193.

Tohidi KB. Gas hydrate equilibria in the presence of electrolyte solutions. Edinburgh: Heriot-Watt University; 1995.

Carroll J. Natural Gas Hydrates, A Guide for Engineers, Gulf Professional Publishing. 2002;232-246.

Aoyagi K, Song KY, Kobayashi R, Sloan ED, Dharmawardhana PB. (I) The water content and correlation of the water content of methane in equilibrium with hydrates (II). The water content of a high carbon dioxide simulated prudhoe bay gas in equilibrium with hydrates; GPA Research Report 45; Tulsa, OK; 1980.

Gillespie PC, Wilson GM. Vapor-liquid and liquid-liquid equilibria: Water-methane, water-carbon dioxide, water-Hydrogen Sulfide, Water-nPentane, Water-Methane-nPentane; GPA Research Report 48; Tulsa, OK; 1982.

Yokoyama C, Wakana S, Kaminishi GI, Takahashi S. Vapor-liquid equilibria in the Methane - diethylene glycol - water system at 298.15 and 323.15 K. Journal of Chemical. Engineering Data. 1988;33: 274-276.

Dohrn R, Buenz AP, Devlieghere F, Thelen D. Experimental measurements of phase equilibria for ternary and quaternary systems of glucose, water, carbon dioxide, and ethanol with a novel apparatus, Fluid Phase Equilibria. 1993;83:149-158.

Song KY, Kobayashi R. The water content of ethane, propane and their mixtures in equilibrium with liquid water or hydrates, Fluid Phase Equilibria. 1994;95: 281-298.

Althaus K. Fortschritt - Berichte VDI. Reihe 3: 350 (in German), Oellrich L.R., Althaus K. GERG - Water Correlation (GERG Technical Monograph TM14) Relationship Between Water Content and Water Dew Point Keeping in Consideration the Gas Composition in the Field of Natural Gas. Fortschritt - Berichte VDI 2000; Reihe 3: Nr. 679 (in English); 1999.

Dhima A, Noll O, Valtz A, Richon D. 18th European Seminar on Applied Thermodynamics, Kutna Hora, Czech Republic; 2000.

Chapoy A. Phase behavior in water/hydrocarbon mixtures involved in gas production systems. Engineering Sciences. _Ecole Nationale Sup_erieure des Mines de Paris; 2004.

Huang S, Leu AD, Ng HJ, Robinson DB. The two-phase behavior of two mixture of methane, carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide and water, Fluid Phase Equilibria. 1985;19: 21-32.

Song KY, Kobayashi R. Water content values of CO2 -5.31 Mol Percent Methane Mixture, GPA Research Report 120, Tulsa; 1989.

Ng HJ, Chen CJ, Schroeder H. Water content of natural gas systems containing acid gas; GPA Research Report 174, Tulsa; 2001.

Aimikhe VJ, Joel OF, Ikiensikimama SS, Iyuke S. Experimental determination of water content of sweet natural gas with methane component below 70%. International Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research. 2017;8(7):2324– 2329.

Maddox RN, Lilly LL, Moshfeghian M, Elizondo E. Estimating water content of sour natural gas mixtures. Laurance Reid Gas Conditioning Conference, Norman, OK; 1988.

Wichert GC, Wichert E. New charts provide accurate estimations for water content of sour natural gas. Oil and Gas Journal. 2003;101(41):64–66.

Li C, Wu X, Jia W, Sun O. New correlations for water content of sweet and sour natural gases. Int. J. Oil, Gas and Coal Technology. 2013;6(4):392–407.

Keenan JH. Steam tables: Thermodynamic properties of water including vapor, Liquid, and Solid Phases, Wiley, New York, USA; 1969.

Zhao LM, Burgass R. Measurement and modeling of water content in low-temperature hydrate-methane and hydrate-natural gas systems. Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data. 2011;56(6):2932–2935.

Gandhidasan P. Parametric analysis of natural gas dehydration by triethylene glycol solution, Energy Sources. 2003; 25(3):189-201.

Mohammadi AH, Sameiyan V, Tohidi B. Estimation of water content in sour gas, Paper 94133 presented at the SPE EUROPEC/EAGE Annual Conference, Madrid, Spain; 2005.

Moshfeghian M; 2014.

Retrieved March 14, 2016, from
Available:http://jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2014/09/lean-sweet-natural-gas-water-content correlation/

Chapoy A, Burgass R, Terrigeol A, Coquelet C. Water content of CO2 rich mixtures: Measurements and modeling using the cubic-plus-association equation of state. Journal of Natural Gas Engineering, John Carroll. 2016;1(13):85-97.

Gas Processors Suppliers Association, GPSA. Engineering Data Book, 11th edition.; Tulsa, OK; 1998.

Mohammadi AH, Richon D. Useful remarks to reduce the experimental information required To determine the equilibrium water content of gas near and inside gas hydrate or ice formation regions. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 2008;47:7-15.

Danesh A. PVT and phase behavior of petroleum reservoir fluids (1st edition). Amsterdam: Elsevier Science B.V; 1998.

Sharma SC, Campbell JM. Predict natural-gas water content with total gas usage. Oil & Gas Journal. 1969;67(31):136-137.

Song KY, Kobayashi R. Measurement and interpretation of the water content of a methane-propane mixture in the gaseous state in equilibrium with hydrate. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Fundamental. 1982;21:391-395.

Song KY, Yarrison M, Chapman W. Experimental low-temperature water content in gaseous methane, liquid ethane, and liquid propane in equilibrium with hydrate at cryogenic conditions. Fluid Phase Equilibria. 2004;224:271–277.

Folas GK, Froyna EW, Lovland J, Kontogeorgis GM, Solbraa E. Data and prediction of water content of high-pressure nitrogen, methane, and natural gas. Fluid Phase Equilibria. 2007;252:162-174.

Terrigeol A, Coquelet C, Chapoy A. Water content assessment in acid gas. GPA Europe, Annual Conference, Florence, Italy; 2015.