Transaction Costs, Extension Support and Equitable Benefit Sharing for Smallholder Farmers in Agricultural Carbon Markets

Sarita Meena *

Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.

Vishnu S. Meena

Department of Agricultural Economics, College of Agriculture, SKNAU, Jobner, Rajasthan, India.

Sanjiv Kumar

Faculty of Agriculture, Jagannath University, Jaipur-303901, India.

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.


Abstract

Background: Agricultural carbon markets are increasingly promoted as a means of financing climate-smart practices on smallholder farms while rewarding farmers for emission reductions and carbon removals. Two decades of project experience nevertheless show modest farmer participation, small and delayed payments, and persistent doubts about the integrity of land-based credits.

Aim and scope: This review critically examines how transaction costs, extension and advisory support, and benefit-sharing arrangements jointly shape whether smallholders in low- and middle-income countries can participate in, and gain from, carbon crediting and related payment schemes for soil carbon, agroforestry, conservation agriculture and rice methane mitigation.

Approach: Peer-reviewed literature published from 2005 onwards was identified through multidisciplinary, economics and agricultural research sources, supplemented by citation tracking and institutional documents, and appraised qualitatively for relevance, design adequacy, transparency and transferability.

Principal findings: The evidence consistently identifies fixed project costs and measurement, reporting and verification requirements as the binding constraint on smallholder inclusion; these costs fall with aggregation but simultaneously concentrate control and revenue among intermediaries. Training and advisory services appear to drive much of the observed practice change, yet their effects are seldom separated from carbon payments, and farmers' trust in delivery agents varies widely. Benefit sharing is frequently skewed towards larger, better-endowed and male-headed households, while revenue reaching farmers is often negligible relative to costs. Integrity reforms that require direct soil measurement or stricter additionality tests may further raise costs and exclude early adopters.

Implications: Integrity, inclusion and cost efficiency cannot be maximised simultaneously; the defensible policy objective is to make the trade-offs explicit through transparent cost and revenue accounting, group-level measurement designs, publicly anchored extension and enforceable distributional rules.

Conclusion: Carbon finance can complement, but not substitute for, agricultural development investment in smallholder systems, and stronger causal and distributional evidence is required before large-scale expansion.

Keywords: Carbon credits, payments for ecosystem services, soil organic carbon, measurement, reporting and verification, agricultural advisory services, climate-smart agriculture, environmental justice, farmer organisations


How to Cite

Meena, Sarita, Vishnu S. Meena, and Sanjiv Kumar. 2026. “Transaction Costs, Extension Support and Equitable Benefit Sharing for Smallholder Farmers in Agricultural Carbon Markets”. Journal of Scientific Research and Reports 32 (11):1398-1423. https://doi.org/10.9734/jsrr/2026/v32i114761.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.